Toronto Islands: The Haunted Gibraltar Point Lighthouse

by May 2, 2018Canada, Toronto0 comments

Opening the doors of Toronto heritage.

Doors Open Toronto

Every year Toronto puts on this awesome event called Doors Open Toronto, which for one weekend, approximately 150 buildings of architectural, historic, cultural, and social significance to the city of Toronto open their doors to the public. For me, this has always been a perfect way to go behind the scenes of building usually closed to the public. The event has since attracted over 1.7 million residents and tourists so in order to enrich the visitor experience many of the participating buildings will offer organized guided tours, exhibits, displays, and activities. I’ve been attending this event since at least 2012, but because you have 2 days to get through, about 150 buildings, scattered across Toronto most of your top picks will inevitably end up shelved for the following year.
However, sometimes Doors Open Toronto offers up some real gems that do not frequently appear on the list of buildings every year. One year I was granted rare entrance to the Osgoode Hall building. Another year I was able to see the abandoned TTC (Toronto Transit Commission) Bay subway station (now used for movies)

Gibraltar Point Lighthouse

A 200-year-old haunted lighthouse

This year another gem popped up on the list. A lighthouse that, until now I never knew existed. The lighthouse itself has been there for 200 years but for 2 days we would be allowed to go inside. The Gibraltar Point Lighthouse dates back to 1808 and is the oldest existing lighthouse on the Great Lakes and one of the oldest buildings in Toronto. Now I could bore you with details about the Gibraltar Point Lighthouse’s height and where the stone used to build it came from but I’m sure your her to learn about the demise of the lighthouse’s first keeper, German-born John Paul Radelmüller. His murder back in 1815 is one of Toronto’s most enduring ghost stories. (For those inquiring mind that like facts; The Gibraltar Point Lighthouse was built to a height of 52 feet (16 m) and extended to 82 feet (25 m) in 1832. The base is made from stone quarried in Queenston and the extension is made from stone quarried in Kingston).

Murder & Intrigue 

The local legend of the haunted lighthouse by its first keeper John Paul Radelmüller goes like this… In 1815 soldiers from Fort York visited Mr. Radelmüller on the evening of January 2, in search of his bootlegged beer. (Sounds like any other typical night here in Toronto’s entertainment district). The soldiers, who had too much to drink, got into a fight which resulted in the keeper’s murder. To make matters worse (as if killing someone wasn’t bad enough) the soldiers tried to conceal their crime by chopping up the corpse and hiding the remains. Fascinated by the story of Mr. Radelmüller, in 1893, George Durnan who served as lightkeeper from 1854-1908 searched for John Paul Radelmüller’s body and found part of a jawbone and coffin fragments near the lighthouse. (However, it was impossible to definitively prove they were linked to Radelmüller)  
[et_pb_posts_carousel_agsdcm category_id=”141″ enable_autoplay=”on” _builder_version=”3.18.9″ posts_per_page=”8″][/et_pb_posts_carousel_agsdcm]


Some of the links in this post are affiliate links. If you purchase a product, I may earn a commission. This commission comes at no extra cost to you. Please remember that I never recommend a product just for the commission — I only recommend something I genuinely believe in, trust and/or use personally. The small income I make here will help in maintaining this blog. Thanks for your support!